![]() |
Mononoke Hime (Princess Mononoke) |
|
Reviews & Articles |
|| Miramax English-language film | Miramax soundtrack CD | Original Japanese-language film ||
Reviews Index |
Reviews of the Miramax English-language version -- Film:
Back to top of Index |
Reviews of the Miramax English-language version -- Soundtrack CD:
Back to top of Index |
Reviews of the original Japanese-language version:
Back to top of Index |
Back to the Reviews & Articles Table of Contents
Reviews of the Miramax English-language version -- Film |
Note: These reviews have been distributed into several pages for ease of access. Please see the Index for links to individual reviews.
|| Reviews 1-20 | Reviews 21-40 | Reviews 41-60 | Reviews 61-80 | Reviews 81-100 | Reviews 101-120 | Reviews 121 and higher ||
Back to Index |
Reviews of the Miramax English-language version -- Soundtrack CD |
1). Film Score Monthly
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://www.filmscoremonthly.com/articles/sep99/30_Sep---Music_for_Anime_Princess_Mononoke.html
September 30, 1999, Thursday
By Jeff Wilson
If you long for an animated film that is meant for those
above the age of ten, you are in luck. Princess Mononoke, the top-grossing
Japanese-made film in that country's history, is to be released by Dimension
Films this fall in a dubbed version that includes Gillian Anderson, Minnie
Driver and Claire Danes among the vocal talent, as well as a script adaptation
by acclaimed fantasy writer Neil Gaiman. [...]
[...]
The score, by regular Miyazaki composer Joe Hisaishi, is without question his
best work. Hisaishi excels at writing beautifully melodic themes, and this
score highlights that. The opening cue, "The Tale of Ashitaka," builds from
slow bass drum beats to a theme that is epic yet restrained, beautiful yet
ambiguous. Miyazaki works hard to make the viewer understand that neither side
is completely right or wrong in the struggle we witness; he forces us to see
all sides of the conflict, and the music needs to recognize this. Hisaishi
provides that music.
[...]
Barring a change, Milan Records is slated to release the soundtrack to Princess
Mononoke October 12th. I hope both film and score will be a success, but the
American public is unlikely to accept an animated film that doesn't involve
rehashed musical numbers and witless animal sidekicks. My only recommendation
is this: if you care about good films, films that make you care about the
characters and their fate, films that are devoid of the vacuous and the
cynical, films made for reasons other than to promote merchandise, then you
should see this film. If you aren't one of those people, see it anyway. [...]
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
2). ScoreLogue
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://www.scorelogue.com/princess_mononoke.html
October 5, 1999, Tuesday
By Vance Brawley (?)
The most anticipated film of the year is already a legend
in Japan as the highest grossing film ever, behind Titanic. Princess Mononoke
tells the story of a young man fighting to escape a deadly curse and a young
princess destined to save the forests from humans. Talk of a Best Picture
nomination, come Oscar time, may be a bit premature, but make no mistake about
it, the score is the best of the year.
[...]
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
3). FilmTracks
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://www.filmtracks.com/titles/princess_mononoke.html
October 5, 1999, Tuesday
By Christian Clemenson (?)
A wildly successful anime film in Japan for two years
now (both in popularity and massive earnings), this film by acclaimed anime
director and animator Hayao Miyazaki is among the first of its kind to receive
a large-scale theatrical release in the United States. A grand tale of
adventure and journeys, the film will be released in the U.S. late in October.
The score for the film has been raising eyebrows ever since the film was first
released a few years ago. Composer Joe Hisaishi, arguably Japan's foremost
composer (having won the country's equivilent of the "Best Score" Academy Award
last year for another project) has worked with Hayao Miyazaki many times
before. During the time early in their collaboration, Hisaishi's music was
often darker and more sinister, and after a few lighter efforts recently,
Princess Mononoke (Mononoke Hime in Japan) marks Hisaishi's return to this
early brooding style. Comparisons have been drawn between the music from
Princess Mononoke and that of Hisaishi's Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind and
Laputa: Castle in the Sky, as well as popular American composers such as Jerry
Goldsmith and James Horner.
[...]
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
4). Cinemusic Online
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://www.cinemusic.net/reviews/1999/princess.html
October 6, 1999, Wednesday
By Helen San
Japanese animator Hayao Miyazaki has an impressive body
of work under his belt, but none so renown and beloved as Mononoke Hime
(Princess Mononoke), the top grossing film of all time in Japan, ousted only by
Titanic. Not to ignore its impressive popularity, Miramax brings it to the
United States on October 29, 1999 with voice dubs by popular American movie
stars (including Billy Crudup, Billy Bob Thornton, Jada Pinkett Smith, and
Gillian Anderson). The fantasy adventure is a mythical legend about a boy
named Ashitaka on a pilgrimage to solve the mystery of a scar and its curse of
death. In this journey, he finds himself in the middle of a war between the
humans who mine the forest (led by Lady Eboshi, voiced by Minnie Driver) and
the gods who protect the forest (led by San/Princesss Mononoke, a human girl
raised by a wolf god, voiced by Claire Danes). If the score is any indication,
the film should be spectacular.
[...]
This score is no doubt one of the most brilliant of this year. There is a
universality and archetype in the music, as though it could accompany the story
of any legend or conflict or hero, which adds an intuitive and profound
connection with the listener. Fitting for a legend, the score resounds with
maturity and an old sense of wisdom. It is hard to imagine any score fan not
falling in love with this one.
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
5). Stay Tooned
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://www.staytooned.com/news/princessmononoke.html
October 8, 1999, Friday
By Evan Backes (?)
[...]
The "Princess Mononoke" soundtrack comprises of a wonderful mix of soft and heavy classical pieces, each setting a different tone in the story. I've listened to this soundtrack close to 12 times straight through and I must admit that it's an excellent supplement to any interested fan. I'm a full-time listener of electronic music as well as classical movements, so the "Princess Mononoke" soundtrack naturally grabbed my attention. There are only two tracks with vocals (in a total of 32 tracks) -one in Japanese and the other (the theme song) sung by Sasha Lazard who has an equally exquisite voice to the Japanese vocals that you can only get overseas.
[...] Go buy the album, listen to it, go see the film and then listen to it again. You can thank me later.
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
6). Hollywood.com
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://sites.hollywood.com/movietunes/soundtracks/reviews/1,1477,princessmonoke,00.html
November 1999
By Hollywood.com
5 out of 5 stars: perfection
[...]
Joe Hisaishi's Princess Mononoke score combines orchestral music with traditional Japanese instrumentation. While mostly instrumental, the soundtrack does feature a couple of short vocal numbers (one in English and one in Japanese). The music, while sounding Western on the surface, subtley incorporates phrases and meters that suggest a Japanese influence. Encompassing a wide range of style and melody, Princess Mononoke brings to us the wonder and mystery of an animated world filled with Demons, Gods, and magic.
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
7). Baltimore Sun
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://www.sunspot.net/cgi-bin/editorial/story.cgi?section=archive&storyid=1150160223485
November 18, 1999, Thursday
By J.D. Considine
As has been obvious since Eisenstein's "Alexander Nevsky," an epic film needs an epic score - and that's as true for animated features as for live-action films. Luckily, Joe Hisaishi's music for Hayao Miyazaki's semi-mythic anime "Princess Mononoke" is epic in every sense of the term. Sure, Hisaishi understands how to underscore the drama on screen, suggesting the dark mysteries of the forest in the low strings and synthesizer that establish "The Legend of Ashitaka," or evoking the warmth and hope of rekindled love through the Rachmaninoff-like flourishes of "Ashitaka and San." But what really gives his score substance is that his melodies are strong enough to stand up almost without orchestration, as Sasha Lazard's heartbreaking rendition of the "Princess Mononoke Theme Song" makes plain.
[...]
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
8). Soundtrack Central
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://altpop.com/stc/reviews/monoprincess.htm
November 1, 1999, Monday
By Adam Corn
Like the film itself, the score to Princess Mononoke (Mononoke Hime) transcends the genre of animation and stands as simply a marvelous piece of film art (in this case film music).
[...]
I'll save further details on the score for the full review, after I've listened through a few more times, which in turn will be after seeing the U.S. release of the film. Even before doing so, I could rave quite a bit more about this score, but it's my initial attraction to the score and the film that has me eagerly wanting to experience the two in tandem. Whether other soundtrack fans as well want to see the film first or not, this CD should be picked up immediately, as it is a wonderful musical experience either way.
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
9). Film Music on the Web
The following are representative quotes only; the full
text is available online at:
http://www.FilmMusic.uk.net/Dec99/princess.htm
December 1999
By Jeffrey Wheeler
Joe Hisaishi is a master of the leitmotif and of clever orchestration. Think of a Japanese John Williams. The soundtrack from "Princess Mononoke" (a film released in 1997, only now reaching the world at large) may take some work getting into, but grasping onto its pulse the score hauls you along a ride of various beauties and terrors. The first things you notice are pleasant enough, but listen closely and you discover so much going on beneath the surface, so much complexity and heart.
True, the score's repetition dulled my initial reaction somewhat severely. It took a few listens before I picked up on the myriad nuances and intricacies that convoke this music to work as a whole, and as I write this, with the score playing behind me, I continue to hear little 'personal discoveries' in this extraordinarily detailed score. [...]
[...]
Unforgettable. The soundtrack has refulgence galore! This is a film score that has a functionality of its own, the sort of dramatic impact to not only support a film but rewrite it so that on top of the film you have the excitement of another unique vision. This is what helps make film music special.
Back to Miramax Soundtrack CD Reviews Index |
Reviews of the original Japanese version |
1). The Daily Yomiuri
July 10, 1997, Thursday
SECTION: Pg. 9
Aaron Gerow Special to The Daily Yomiuri ; Yomiuri
It is testimony to the importance of animation in the world of Japanese film that the most successful filmmaker in any genre in the last 13 years--both financially and critically--has without a doubt been Hayao Miyazaki. His epic tales of chivalry and the powers of nature, speaking to generations young and old, have consistently topped the box office charts while simultaneously expanding the horizons of animation and earning him a worldwide following.
Now that he is hinting at retiring, The Princess Mononoke arrives to marvelously encapsulate his brilliant career, though not without revealing one or two signs of aging.
The mythic story clearly returns to familiar Miyazaki territory. In an age long ago, when everything in nature still bore its own "spirit," the young Ashitaka is forced to leave his northern birthplace after a wild boar, somehow transformed into a demon of revenge, attacks his village and leaves the young man with a mysterious wound.
Hoping for a cure, he sets out south and west in search of the legendary all-powerful Shishigami, (lion-like god) until he happens upon a village that is brutally mining the hillsides for iron. That rape of nature has incurred the wrath of Moro, the Wolf Spirit, who attacks the village repeatedly along with San, a human girl who can communicate with the nature spirits and thus earns the name Princess Mononoke (literally, spirits of things).
Ashitaka urges peace between San and the village's female chieftain, Eboshi, but his efforts are thwarted by even greater powers bent on killing the Shishigami and transforming nature into mere objects for humankind to use. What enfolds is a battle over the future of nature itself.
That Princess Mononoke does not necessarily end on a happy note brings this film in line with others of Miyazaki's works--from the masterful Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind (1984) to the decidedly pessimistic Pom Poko (1994, produced by Miyazaki and directed by his Studio Ghibli partner, Isao Takahata)--that plea for humanity to live in harmony with nature.
Helping to ground this environmentalism is a compelling animistic world-view, also found in the delightful My Neighbor Totoro (1988), not far removed from Japanese Shinto beliefs. Unlike some of Miyazaki's more mythic creations, Mononoke is most definitely rooted in Japan and its culture.
But Japan--that is, the land of Yamato--does not come off very well in the movie. Ashitaka's northern people resemble the Ainu and Eboshi an Izumo leader while the bad guys are definitely played by the samurai-clad agents of the Yamato emperor. This kind of valorization of defeated ethnicities resonates with both the film's political correctness--especially in the women-led society of Eboshi's village--and its longing for an irretrievable past.
Yet as both nostalgia and myth, Mononoke remains, as with much of Miyazaki's work, temporally and geographically ambiguous, speaking more to universal than local concerns. This may explain his popularity abroad and why Buena Vista, a Disney company, has opted to distribute this and other Studio Ghibli films in the United States.
The Princess Mononoke does stray at times from the center of the Miyazaki path. It most notably lacks the thrilling flying scenes that have dominated so much of the director's works, replacing them with short but exciting digitally produced shots of motion through space, such as of Ashitaka's arrow zooming toward its target. That the arrow usually ends up lopping off an arm or head emphasizes that this is not a children's movie.
At best, one can say that The Princess Mononoke is a powerful compilation of Miyazaki's world, a cumulative statement of his moral and filmic concerns; at worst, that the director may be losing his originality in his old age. But in either case, the creations of the cultural icon Miyazaki have certainly begun to function on the level of myth: No matter how many times we see them, they never cease to entertain and teach us.
Back to Japanese-language Film Reviews Index |
Friday January 30
Princess Mononoke (Mononoke Hime) (Animated, Japanese, Color, no rating, 2:13)
By Leonard Klady
HOLLYWOOD (Variety) - Japan's all-time box office champ, "Princess Mononoke," is a rich cartoon fable of bygone gods locking horns with man and with industry, which threatens to unbalance the forces of nature.
Though set in the 14th century, its ecological bias and feminist slant provide a modern resonance. But the picture -- steeped in Asian folklore -- will require shrewd translation to connect with Western audiences. A few deft brush strokes could result in strong theatrical returns and extremely buoyant cassette sales. The animator could reap a bounty from all revenue streams as it ushers in a Japanese animation franchise.
(Disney recently concluded a multipicture acquisition of films by Mononoke director Hayao Miyazaki that will include theatrical and video releases in the U.S. and other territories. Mononoke will open via Miramax in the summer.)
Flying in the face of popular Western animation, Princess Mononoke is not a musical, nor is it primarily directed at preteens, even if that group can readily embrace it. The film represents a bold experiment for Miyazaki, whose earlier work, including Kiki's Delivery Service, The Red Pig and My Neighbor Totoro, had more gentle, youthful themes. The new film, which has grossed more than $150 million in Japan, is not only more sharply drawn, it has an extremely complex and adult script.
The tale begins in Japan's distant and sparsely populated north. In the opening section, young Prince Ashitaka is valiantly fighting off a demon god -- a giant boar seemingly possessed by wormlike creatures. After the prince slays the beast, the village oracle begs its forgiveness, but it has already left its curse on the prince and infected him with a fatal disease. He's told by the seer that he must venture to the west to have the malediction lifted.
The journey evolves into a mystical and violent pilgrim's progress. He encounters bloodthirsty samurai, a corrupt priest and cuddly, docile forest gnomes. Eventually, the prince arrives at the great forest and is befriended by Lady Eboshi, who operates a giant ironworks on its periphery.
Ashitaka finds himself thrust into the middle of several conflicts. Eboshi's clan is in danger of attack by rivals. The great struggle however, is between the factory and the forest families of boars, wolves and the like who are being killed off to make way for industrial expansion. For centuries, the woodland denizens have controlled their turf, but this woman has a powerful secret that's turned the tables -- gunpowder.
Allegiances are further clouded by the arrival of the title character, also known as San. She not only runs with the wolves, she considers herself one of them. San does not know what to make of the young stranger. And though each side considers him friend or foe at various stages, Ashitaka ultimately wants to reconcile the two and find the deer god who can cure his affliction.
In keeping with the best of Disney's toon features, Mononoke develops full characters, obscuring the lines separating it from live-action fare. Eboshi is not some cardboard villain; rather, she is a force of the future, employing society's misfits, such as lepers and ex-prostitutes, and giving them the chance to find dignity in work. She's also headstrong and incapable of backing down once she's thrust into battle.
Pic shares an eco theme with Miyazaki's earlier Pom Poko, but it is much richer, drawing upon the nation's history and adapting folkloric legends for a highly original tale. Princess Mononoke has the soul of a romantic epic, and its lush tones, elegant score by Joe Hisaishi and full-blooded characterizations give it the sweep of cinema's most grand canvases.
Voices:
Ashitaka ........ Yoji Matsuda
San ............. Yuriko Ishida
Lady Eboshi ..... Yuko Tanaka
Jiko ............ Kaori Kobayashi
Koroku .......... Masahiko Nishimura
Gonza ........... Tsunehiko Kamijyo
Toki ............ Sumi Shimamoto
Moro ............ Akihiro Miwa
Oracle .......... Mitsuko Mori
Okkoto .......... Hisaya Morishige
A Miramax Films (U.S.) release of a Tokuma Shoten Co.-Nippon Television Network-Dentsu-Studio Ghibli production. Produced by Toshio Suzuki. Executive producer, Yasuyoshi Tokuma.
Directed, written by Hayao Miyazaki. Animation direction, Masashi Ando, Kitaro Kosaka, Yoshifumi Kondo. Camera (Fujicolor, Panavision widescreen), Atsushi Okui; editor, Takeshi Seyama, Miyazaki; music, Joe Hisaishi; sound (Dolby Digital), Kazuhiro Wakabayashi. Reviewed at Ticketmaster Screening Room, L.A., Jan. 27, 1998.
Reuters/Variety
Back to Japanese-language Film Reviews Index |